Bags: pre-purchase judging points
7 judging points, listed exhaustively and ordered by what cannot be undone. Last checked .
What goes wrong most often here
For bags the two failures that come up most are these: hardware that looks correct in a wide shot but has no weight once you hold the strap, and edge paint that hides a raw cut on the corners until the first week of use. Both are decided by photographs a seller can take before dispatch, which is why the points below start where they do.
Bags are bulky for their value, so volumetric weight and the carrier tier decide more of the delivered total than the listing price does.
Every judging point for this category
7 points, read in an order set by what cannot be undone. For bags that works out as 1 at the deal credibility stage, 3 at the structural defects stage, 3 at the surface and finish stage.
Deal credibility 1
- Batch identity: does the named version match the build?Whether a version confirmed in writing before payment matches the build markers on the item that arrives.Current26 Sep 2026
Structural defects 3
- Hardware plating, tone and heftTone and surface of the metal parts, the pull of magnets and clasps, and what one piece weighs for its size.Current23 Sep 2026
- Interior stamp and date code placementWhere the interior stamp and date code sit, how deep the impression goes, and the letterform spacing.Current24 Sep 2026
- Strap load points where leather meets metalHow the strap joins the bag at each ring, and whether stitching and rivets there survive a loaded lift.Current25 Sep 2026
Surface and finish 3
- Stitch pitch around curves and cornersWhether stitch spacing holds where a seam turns, and whether the line keeps its distance from the edge.Current22 Sep 2026
- Lining, seam binding and pocket workThe lining material, how raw seam allowances are covered, and how the interior pockets are finished.Current27 Sep 2026
- Edge paint coverage and corner buildWhether the cut edges are sealed at every layer, and how the corners are turned, folded or left open.Current28 Sep 2026
What the photographs have to cover
For bags, 6 distinct things have to be visible in the set a seller sends — beginning with the platform message thread, screenshot showing the date and the seller's reply naming a version and a colourway:
- the platform message thread, screenshot showing the date and the seller's reply naming a version and a colourway
- public comparison photos for the same version word, plus the storefront's own older listings of that model
- one continuous clip of 30 to 60 seconds, bag on a plain surface, no cuts, the seller's hand turning it
- arrival photos taken at the same angles as the clip, read beside the exported message thread from step 1
- one photo per metal part in indirect daylight, with a plain white sheet of paper held beside the metal as a colour reference
- the frames from step 1 laid side by side, examined at the highlight rather than in the shadow
Asking for that set in one message is what the photo request wording is for. When a seller skips one of these shots, the gap surfaces first at batch identity: does the named version match the build?, which is why that point sits at the top of the list above. What each angle can and cannot show is set out on the photo limits page.
Cost shape for this category
Bags are bulky for their value, so volumetric weight and the carrier tier decide more of the delivered total than the listing price does.
3 gauges cover this category, listed beside this column with the date each parameter set was last read. On bags orders the line that moves first is bags are bulky for their value.
Records for this category
- Structured handbags, coated canvas and leather-look exteriorsLevel E3 · n=57 · known for top-handle totes, shoulder bags, gold-tone hardwareRetired21 Sep 2026
- Soft leather-look shoulder bags and crossbody stylesLevel E4 · n=46 · known for pebbled-finish panels, adjustable straps, magnetic closuresCurrent21 Sep 2026
- Small leather goods and compact carry, hardware-ledLevel E3 · n=22 · known for card holders, belt bags, chain strapsCurrent25 Sep 2026
All seller records, with the inclusion and withdrawal rules on the method page.