Judging deskdhgatecode

Chest measurement against the tag size

CurrentLast checked Surface and finishJerseys

Whether the chest measurement a listing prints for a tag size matches what the shirt of that size measures.

The reading sequence

3 steps, starting at surface and finish and running to convert the figures and compare them with a shirt you own. Evidence on this point is read at E1 or E3, and 2 of the 3 steps carries a condition that ends the assessment outright.

Step 1

Write down both numbers before asking for anything

Establish what the listing itself claims, so a later answer from the seller can be compared with the page rather than with memory.

Evidence: E3 — the listing's size table and the tag size in its title, copied out as text with the date you read them

Pass
  • The table prints a pit-to-pit figure for each tag size it offers.
  • The tag size in the title matches a row in the table.
  • The table states whether the figure is the garment laid flat or the body it fits.
Query
  • The table gives a body range such as fits chest 96 to 101 cm, with no garment figure.
  • Two sizes share one figure, which usually means a copy error rather than a cut.
Return
  • No measurement appears anywhere on the listing.
  • The size table is an image that cannot be read at full size.
Step 2

Ask for the shirt measured flat with a tape in frame

Get the same measurements the listing claims, taken on the actual shirt with a scale visible in the same photo.

Evidence: E1 — three photos of one shirt with the tape laid across the chest 2 cm below the armhole, down the body length, and across the sleeve, with the tag readable in at least one of them

Pass
  • The tape is visible in all three photos and the tag is readable in one.
  • The chest is measured at the same point the listing names.
Query
  • Two of the three measurements are supplied with the tape in frame.
  • The tape is shown but placed at a different point from the one the listing names.
Return
  • No tape appears in any photo, so the figures cannot be read off the shirt.
  • The seller answers the size question with a sentence such as true to size.
  • The tag is not shown anywhere with the shirt that was measured.
Stop here if: The seller answers a size question with a sentence twice and never sends a tape in frame. A written claim with no measurement behind it cannot be checked against the goods once they have been worn. What to do next.
Step 3

Convert the figures and compare them with a shirt you own

Turn the printed figure and the photographed figure into one unit that can be checked against a shirt already in the wardrobe.

Evidence: E3 — the size bridge with the listing figure, the photographed figure and one home shirt's flat measurement entered side by side

Pass
  • The photographed chest is within 2 cm of the figure printed on the same listing.
  • The same tag size is within 4 cm of the home shirt measured flat.
Query
  • The photographed chest is 3 to 4 cm away from the printed figure.
  • The tag size is 5 to 6 cm away from the home shirt, which one wash may explain.
Return
  • The photographed chest is more than 5 cm from the figure printed on the same listing.
  • A shirt tagged M measures as an XL against the home shirt in the same tag size.
Stop here if: The photographed chest is more than 5 cm from the figure printed on the same listing and the seller will not restate it in writing. That gap is wider than any fit preference can absorb, and no exchange will close it after wearing. What to do next.

Why the thresholds sit where they do

Tag size on a shirt is a label, not a measurement, and the two part company most often on light knit fabric that shrinks and stretches. The order here is deliberate: the listing figure is recorded first so the seller's answer has something to be compared against, the photograph is requested second so the answer carries a scale, and the conversion comes last because it needs both figures. The 2 cm band is where two people measuring the same shirt flat stop disagreeing, and the 4 cm band against a home shirt allows for the shrinkage one wash cycle adds. Neither band is a fit judgement; both mark the point at which the goods and the page disagree.

Common misreads

3 pairs recorded for this point. Each runs in both directions: 1 finding that looks worse than it is, and 2 that looks better.

Check this point against what you were sent

Insufficient evidence

Nothing decided on chest measurement versus tag size yet: 0 of 3 steps have been read.

0 of 3 steps judged

One row per step. Evidence levels: E1 seller photos before dispatch, E2 your photos after arrival, E3 platform public information, E4 third-party reference only. This covers one judging point; the sequence as a whole is scored on the photo scorecard.
StepReadingEvidenceStop met
1. Write down both numbers before asking for anythingneeds E3—
2. Ask for the shirt measured flat with a tape in frameneeds E1The seller answers a size question with a sentence twice and never sends a tape in frame. A written claim with no measurement behind it cannot be checked against the goods once they have been worn.
3. Convert the figures and compare them with a shirt you ownneeds E3The photographed chest is more than 5 cm from the figure printed on the same listing and the seller will not restate it in writing. That gap is wider than any fit preference can absorb, and no exchange will close it after wearing.
Score the whole category

Sources and checks

Last checked · next review due · status current.

Compare current jerseys listings

Return to Jerseys: pre-purchase judging points, or read how verdicts are defined on the method page.